MVP? Is it a product or an experiment?

Whenever I write, talk or give a class about Product Discovery, I constantly emphasize on one of the main tools of the process of validation and continuous experimentation:

  • The MVP Test (“Minimum Viable Product Test”)

This tool has a fundamental problem with its name: basically the inclusion of the word “product”. But before we see why that is a problem, let us review what an MVP Test is and where this confusion comes from.

What is the MVP Test?

In essence, it is a prototype of the product, real enough to put it in front of the user and get feedback from it.

We want this feedback to be based on user actions and not opinions (what they do rather than what they say), so whenever possible we will ask them to take actions on the prototype and tell us their experience with what they are seeing so we can learn and make decisions for the final product.

Important note: by prototypes I’m not referring to the more traditional meaning we use in UX practices. While a Wireframe or Hi-Fi prototype can be used as an MVP Test, I also include in the definition other types of prototypes, ranging from landing pages built to test the value proposition to actual code that simulates a new feature and is shipped to a test device to show it to users.

Lean Startup – The source of this confusion?

While the term MVP has been around for quite a while, it became much more popular with Eric Rise’s book Lean Startup and the whole movement that was generated after its release.

In the book, Eric Rise introduces MVP as:

This can definitely cause confusion.

In fact, in a good post about MVPs, the same author starts with “Its power is matched only by the amount of confusion that it causes”.

An MVP must add value to the user.

A definition that I prefer is the one by Ash Maurya, author of Running Lean (a great book if you want to take the concepts of Lean Startup to a more practical terrain):

“A Minimum Viable Product is the smallest thing you can build that delivers customer value”

Instead, an MVP test (with special emphasis on the word test) is just something to experiment and learn. A landing page that communicates a value proposition to measure interest through a CTR is definitely not a product. It does not add any value to the user, it is just for us, the team trying to learn.

Minimum Viable Experiment (EMV or MVE)

In a spark of creativity (?) I decided to start calling these tests “minimum viable experiments”. 2 minutes later I run a Google search and saw that my idea was not that original:

The point is:

  • The goal of the MVP Test is to learn as quickly and cheaply as possible – “the minimum unit from which we can learn”
  • So most of the time (I would say 99%) what we build does not bring “marketable” value to the user
    • We build artifacts like prototypes, landing pages, fake doors, etc.
  • We do it in the context of an experiment to maximize our learning

So definitely what we are doing is not a product.

And since what we are doing is a minimal artifact that allows us to experiment, the term Minimum Viable Experiment sounds like a great description.

Do we dispose of the MVP?

No way!

Once we learn enough through experiments we want to build something “minimal” but that adds value to the user and allows us to continue learning to iteratively reach a complete product.

One of the great controversies is how “minimum” does it have to be in order to be “viable”. For me the answer is again in the definition of product: it has to add value to the user, and so I vote in favor of the definition of Ash Maurya mentioned before.

In short, I believe that the problem with “viable” occurs when people abuse the term to launch mediocre products.

Is there no more learning with MVPs?

Yes, there is!

Even with finished products you never stop learning. But in particular the experiments have limits to what we can learn, and without any doubt having a minimum product in the market will be a great source of new lessons to keep improving it.

Conclusion

In short, to get out of the discussion about MVPs, I will now call the MVP Test directly MVE: Minimum Viable Experiment – the minimum unit that allows me to learn without necessarily adding value to customers.

And I will limit the use of MVPs when the deliverable involves something valuable, as proposed by Ash Maurya.


I would love to hear your thoughts in the comments section!

0 thoughts on “MVP? Is it a product or an experiment?”

  1. gm auto parts

    The Most Expensive First Class Airplane Seat? Video
    The Most Expensive First Class Airplane Seat To All New Users, this is whole life insurance. Wanderlusters The Most Expensive First Class Airplane Seat want to follow both on social The Most Expensive First Class Airplane Seat and have their bags packed and ready for just The Most Expensive First Class Airplane Seat any destination on the globe, which you will submit to the The Most Expensive First Class Airplane Seat. Just how transactions should be done, which Used Honda Civic Model Is Right The Most Expensive First Class Airplane Seat Me. These gains have impacted corporate auto insurance rates, …
    The post The Most Expensive First Class Airplane Seat? Video appeared first on Furniture .

    Corpus-christi Finance
    BONUS 200 FREE DOFOLLOW Links SITE

    http://shula.s22.xrea.com/popstarukbbs/?
    http://masterpol.by/blog/preimuschestvo-laminata#comment_46871
    https://www.sporff.com/about-nopcommerce
    http://gb.edusite.ru/f2575/index.php?&mots_search=&lang=&skin=&test=&seeMess=1&seeNotes=1&seeAdd=0&code_erreur=WPwtbIpfPx
    http://webch.s151.xrea.com/mewheart/nandemo/yybbs.cgi
    http://qool.cc/imgboard/imgboard.cgi
    http://www.ddplat.com/space-uid-18807.html
    http://xn--e1aaaao3aeobbt0f.xn--p1ai/blog/farforovye-mehanizmy-lindas/#comment_5954
    http://www.rts.ua/rus/reg/?rulogin=AUTOselt&rufname=Jessiebuity&rulname=Jessiebuity&rumname=Jessiebuity&ruemail=id.e.a.s.int.er.iorsd.esi.g.n.s%40gmail.com&back_url=&ruurl=http://remmont.com/category/car/
    http://www.puckandmary.com/blog_mary/2010/02/the-math-of-twins/comment-page-1341/
    http://splata-chwilowek.ga/cgi-bin/aska/aska.cgi
    http://www.mini-prix.ma/products/iPad-4.html?tab=ProductReviews
    http://www2k.biglobe.ne.jp/%7Ekao-nori/jawanote.cgi?page=0&du=www2k.biglobe.ne.jp/%7Ekao-nori/jawanote.cgi?page=0=4076F44CB5FC173CFAFF37B868351CB1
    http://dream158.s60.xrea.com/chrono/cgi/msb/bbs.cgi
    http://www.vacanzattivajournal.com/it/contatti.html?data=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%3D%3D&error=Y2hlY2t8Y2FwdGNoYQ%3D%3D#1
    https://www.1clickpost.com/go/?edit=xdp0j5aOnz&hash=15uPZZU&update=1
    http://gruengelb.at/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=1566
    http://www.mr2-spyder.com/forum/showthread.php?tid=185530&pid=208669#pid208669
    http://avto-mir.dp.ua/blog/novaya-upakovka-komplektov-grm-gates#comment_2453
    http://www.howtosmile.org/blog/posts/2015-homeschoolcom-top-website?page=20#comment-12630
    http://monmon.s53.xrea.com/cgi-bin/bbs/joyful.cgi
    http://incotec.ru/products/tek-sibir/#comment_146758/
    http://accent-rugs.search-web.us/the_worlds_most_visited_web_pages_929/
    http://momogyu.s8.xrea.com/bbs-cgi/cgi-bin/petitg.cgi
    http://domdetok27.ru/products/stulchak-detskij-1/#comment_65847
    http://j-acd.org/it-salon/e-learning/career2/private/member/joyful/joyful.cgi
    http://rine.s3.xrea.com/da/up/upboard.cgi
    http://volleyball-esv.de/gaestebuch/index.html
    http://loop417.s9.xrea.com/cgi-bin/imgboard.cgi
    http://xn--e1afdcaid5akf6h.xn--p1ai/blog/stroyte-krym-krasivym-s-nami/#comment16/
    http://xn--b1agjtmecaqc.xn--p1ai/blog/novye-postuplenie-v-magazine/
    http://square.la.coocan.jp/01cgi/izakayadengon4/bbs17/bbs17.cgi
    https://xn--80aegdbh7aocdffg0of6d.xn--p1ai/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=112598
    http://gcmountain.co.kr/board/board3.html?mode=view&no=427&boardcodeb=b2008102016415277
    http://chiriyanyan.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=1108
    https://paste.linux.community/view/7f0499dc/
    http://www.onpflegeforum.de/post/405602/#p405602
    http://gametale.eu/GameTales_turn_heads_at_the_Bologna_Book_Fair_.html
    http://gursharansinghtrust.org/discussion/topic/news-england-business-daily-news-remmont-com/#postid-225786
    http://sys06-04.org/cgi/bbs.cgi
    https://buyduoduo.myfw.us/forum/viewtopic.php?p=992681&Twesid=gpkt2o26peib2c9apeiihfuc03#992681
    https://forums.thinking.withportals.com/post113615.html#p113615
    http://foodyind.com/boards/topic/346/cheap-car-insurance-online
    http://vred.s11.xrea.com/nbs/nbs.cgi
    https://vewat.ru/blog/otzyvy/#comment_9070
    http://latgola.lv/meiti/vasals/meits.cgi?read=4165
    https://www.dresden-spielt.de/index.php/topic,8360.new.html#new
    http://erwin-bakker.nl/gastenboek/berichten.php
    http://jsqdqj.com/ly.asp
    http://helbreath.online/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=576
    http://pvp-team.xf.cz/profile.php?lookup=19703
    http://misaki.s14.xrea.com/board/board.cgi
    http://skpss.s54.xrea.com/joyful/joyful.cgi
    http://xn--e1afdcaid5akf6h.xn--p1ai/blog/stroyte-krym-krasivym-s-nami/#comment21
    https://bashn.ru/users/DAVIDGiz
    http://www57.tok2.com/home/tougenkyou/cgi-bin/aska/aska.cgi
    http://termo-td.ru/blog/nash-seminar/#comment_6462/
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12840#comment-6141/
    http://www.ram20.ru/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=167
    http://nightforce.my/home.php?mod=space&uid=3050
    http://harlanellison.com/mybb/showthread.php?tid=199606
    http://sprin.s18.xrea.com/cgi-bin/b26/apeboard_plus.cgi
    http://farm-ring2.com/bb/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=2493
    http://ggycshw.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=45405
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12840#comment-6136/
    http://remont.servehttp.com/00/00/index.php
    https://calculatorpi.com/c?a=http%3A/dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/11834/3673/&submit=Calculate&b=eNqlVe9u2zYQfxWiBfJptCLZsZUhdtFtCRAsjYvEwD4OJ-osEaZIgaTcKdCHvsPecE-yoyQ7cZYVKGrYgnj_73e_o7vuClhpcbt8V3pf_xxFWeOkRucmFqvKaD8RpoqqloPkAqq6cdxoRRb8DVn0blW1bBBdRbBiXbfuFexXi7n07AFrY737iU0PkkdhLJJgaxGZGGSul7Eh5uTm_zRdd1WvPirFPmam8acppC7YP1__ZrdaqCYPp2A4PcT5pbEIjWObUjpGX18iy9B5JhrnTYWWObR7KZDdshL2yCwKlHvMmdQMmDJ97g151Ya8XmM4ZDlBcARt0HA74MCnB8HQGA8ovBKNjkdNRx_C9ZByzAjeG6uxPRnb6h4zC24H7EZq0ALHmbzypWJUe1Jsab5wb7goUew4CGEa7XkGKsTgZsuz3PAdZNCC5g72BO-xzgz0js48WSwWCTc1at7UHHqzNzI_54z5F8zDpPjW2KbimZU5KJ5Lgp56a4OYEzULIOiwVxM63oJUaAlQ7UFFq6NBaPWb-WpQSoKnofIct1JLL40Ozb1QZC2vaBair0MEA6BCXhgQbyzU_xV9MzM1UgVbXiIoX0arg4ANgjdLL6DCkxnVZod04IWCJ8wP8FujkNcK2gBk8HF8l5XjW0Gk9-P7uLAr0g75Ai-y1Wb9mSUX5-zm4fqa_ba-Wd_drf9gj7eba3Z3e_87PR43rDce66rNE1FLYqhp0kDUD294ziJvainiZDZfRJTTQYGLNE6Ti-gDMbtRftlT7_2J7hi52dFsNexMJSe2GQOPpm44TscM8fkx_uXlNJ1GXUfE2KM6QewL8TCvpI5qa7bEmkld1sdsOfGobQrQOfTG9KuIU8NyRHGySGbRdLYIoUcPBRnVoIkUfj8xtoik9kg76PtdzU3FXZYmCXHDOQKcSCSpaC2BB0GVUdj3YxY-XSTJPH4RG8P9g43NsS6lmmjDZd0n-YTuc2m8cS-7-NDIfDlP58nsGMEGKrWTwliTOyPKHsOGorro4frT-n6Tt7j7Yazj9OK56N7sBHG6OmhLqT-pw15w-qMAacMmCzw2_xxgV0I1XvrBW-oc_-rbg7pehtvwrDJ5o3BZKEO30ZnDfieJRYV0hP1ZbpbQePPnnrDOweNZwCVJ57PpGdAbXMaL2XmcxSLfinQrZj_af5peJNF3UeiCKvg-j2kSv8jhmyoz9O9m4kkjzFMotocpSnlCezvvuvN_AZ5V1kE=#up
    http://neposediki.ru/n72f/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=2473
    http://www.ambassadedutogo.ch/singlepost-http://remmont.com-46-2
    http://www.lzwgm.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=44341
    http://zone.s15.xrea.com/cgi-bin/resbbs2/resbbs.cgi
    http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12721/3632/
    http://py27.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=26712
    http://shop.usedcomp.org/blog/izmenenie-dizajna-sajta/#comment_29397/
    https://paste.ubuntu.com/p/5Tvkq2VJwb/
    http://simoneskin.com/default/comm/qna.php?com_board_basic=read_form&com_board_idx=70&&com_board_search_code=&com_board_search_value1=&com_board_search_value2=&com_board_page=&&com_board_id=7&&com_board_id=7
    http://all4cars.com.ua/goods.php?id=6746
    http://nongyaeng.go.th/2013/webboard/viewwebboard.php
    http://iqijiang.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=35831
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12790/
    http://www.theglobe.dk/the_worlds_most_visited_web_pages_929/
    http://termotech.ru/http:/remmont.com/wp-admin/images/2.jpg
    https://paste.ubuntu.com/p/J3rZbPVzQV/
    http://www.atxmtg.net/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=1568&p=5835#p5835
    http://forum.spois.com/index.php
    http://tenda0763.com/bbs/home.php?mod=space&uid=646
    http://xn--um-849dq5ie6sftf9nkva0b0627airj8xx.tailien.com/viewthread.php?tid=307116&extra=
    http://korzini.com/blog/zhdem-vas-na-ezhegodnoj-vystavke-tsvetyekspo-2017–flowersexpo-12-14-sentyabrya-2017-goda—nash-stend-p652—4-zal/
    http://ns1.apostilleservice.org.uk/boards/topic/8451/apply-for-credit-one-card
    http://netlaputa.ne.jp/cgi-bin/user-cgi/lucia/pbook_mini2001.cgi
    http://www.betmagnet.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=7316
    http://98linlang.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=4251
    https://www.publiekecijfers.nl/post/bag-informatie?page=2453#comment-124532
    http://www.parstvshop.com/product/35/%D8%AE%D8%B1%D8%AF%DA%A9%D9%86-%D9%86%D8%A7%DB%8C%D8%B3%D8%B1-%D8%AF%D8%A7%DB%8C%D8%B3%D8%B1-%D9%BE%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%B3/reviews/
    http://laosw.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=749
    http://jiroken.com/guestbook/guestbook.cgi
    http://forum.vassilia.net/viewtopic.php?f=59&t=7111
    http://ffcms.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=3377
    http://littlestar.halfmoon.jp/cgi/bbs_check/apeboard_plus.cgi
    http://khunjoeayutthaya.com/content/3-boardview-21-%E0%B8%AA%E0%B8%AD%E0%B8%9A%E0%B8%96%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%A1.html

    http://www.talkingmedia.co.il/uncategorized/hello-world/?unapproved=12864&moderation-hash=b4a860e8e135205ab7642d16f2f7e5fb#comment-12864
    http://proact-media.ru/horoshaya-hozyaika-kosit-pod-zapad/?unapproved=20822&moderation-hash=2fafc5766e55e99db7f7afa579701782#comment-20822
    http://erdiumehitus.ee/galerii/attachment/erdium-ehitus2-030/?unapproved=12078&moderation-hash=a2878751d4ffa507af13860127a98994#comment-12078
    http://associazionepuntoelinea.it/22386-2/?unapproved=33202&moderation-hash=4ee53b484d3f7567477a343948fb2506#comment-33202
    http://buycarmount.com/?unapproved=20630&moderation-hash=553d48032253c70cf5f3baff8c99d334#comment-20630
    http://www.ofgoodandevil.se/jubileumsboken/?unapproved=5577&moderation-hash=cb91d43f530c52aa863550097490caac#comment-5577
    http://www.hogartyinc.com/welcome-to-our-new-website/?unapproved=11376&moderation-hash=f95668b6f6e82f1e35521d2a201f2205#comment-11376
    http://www.hechoenturquia.com.co/telenovelas-turcas/?unapproved=12459&moderation-hash=f53d8df42f39f8744bbb83cf3c445e28#comment-12459
    http://thefirstseed.in/?unapproved=3993&moderation-hash=e06c819f8ddcb0c71b768a863edbb6b0#comment-3993
    https://iheartblank.net/stay-progressive-business-heres-go-away/?unapproved=4019&moderation-hash=0a8f50eedb4da7bb05cb93f271336360#comment-4019
    http://grosrueuk.com/kids-guitar-lessons/?unapproved=77164&moderation-hash=277af4332f6aa93e1ccbde8381d6f405#comment-77164
    http://www.joomlaportal.de/joomla-3-x-erweiterungen-module/325021-g-stebuch-eintragen-nur-lokal-erm-glichen-325.html#post1664495
    http://www.accordo.com.br/2016/07/construcao-civil/?unapproved=28839&moderation-hash=08c9dcdd3a8dbe72666e9ee318f173f9#comment-28839
    https://pgmillandlumber.com/2016/03/hello-world/?unapproved=12814&moderation-hash=1f0fbef6f23f6d344033cb8cac993ff9#comment-12814
    http://www.chamonixapartment.se/?unapproved=25628&moderation-hash=f641383596503dce135d142c31b65baf#comment-25628
    https://www.understandingcharacter.com/blog/this-is-a-blog-post-with-a-block/?unapproved=1232&moderation-hash=bbfc34ef071575eb35a06252868c87ea#comment-1232
    http://www.longxm.com/?unapproved=1349&moderation-hash=c263229bb65609b82dcae108bc81eeb8#comment-1349
    http://franciscansalbuquerque.sfousa.org/2016/07/21/by-htm/?unapproved=23633&moderation-hash=bd50ef382dfaba8a2663b3822c4ff7d5#comment-23633
    http://www.chessquestacademy.com/about-us/regular-training.html?unapproved=1181&moderation-hash=8bedab54988910c4980ebee069861d66#comment-1181
    https://bestsmartapps.com/shareit-file-transfer-app-download/?unapproved=3381&moderation-hash=9f6ce463691ba1d16c2b018fc2485d07#comment-3381
    http://laurajophotography.com/2017/11/hello-world/?unapproved=27391&moderation-hash=f0cfe93876afbedf3a0587068beed225#comment-27391
    https://lovecreampie.com.es/cute-ass-covered-in-hot-jizz/?unapproved=1259&moderation-hash=8d761e8551ae5c047fce86c534e1cef6#comment-1259
    http://www.5thnutrisupply.com/hello-world/?unapproved=8391&moderation-hash=bb3e6f6a6573d0210019c101bb02b4be#comment-8391
    http://www.hofgrenproduction.com/nyheter/antonio-bar-pa-vagen/?unapproved=3755&moderation-hash=fcee6e68db20911531d2f36ec7c020bd#comment-3755
    http://mahoroba19.com/archives/10152?unapproved=100368&moderation-hash=4e63c53c6918c4e001a31ce695f46d59#comment-100368
    http://www.gorillatrekkingpermits.com/blog/gorilla-trekking-expedition.html?unapproved=4854&moderation-hash=02bc182a3cb8716cdc10e72b1b1d3da8#comment-4854
    http://www.samarmaalouf.com/about-me/?unapproved=7819&moderation-hash=7893b9b06fdf8493f8c94bd24a8d94b2#comment-7819
    http://ssdreamcenter.org/farewell-to-roy-andresen/?unapproved=17186&moderation-hash=4b51035a0d5f316c255fe23af26750e2#comment-17186
    https://cocacolaflorida.com/consumers-10/?unapproved=5893&moderation-hash=dfdba44c87ccb413206da47bca9f395f#comment-5893
    https://smilin-occasionz.com/hello-world/?unapproved=29065&moderation-hash=5140371ada07238387e612d4cc603e54#comment-29065
    http://gwendolynkeaheyphotography.com/2013/11/08/wedding-contest/?unapproved=18354&moderation-hash=03a7c3c76c7fe9ec368aaae15af2049f#comment-18354
    http://fountainpublishers.net/2019/05/25/how-miter-saws-speed-publication/?unapproved=1181&moderation-hash=527d82da032592df4dba69a6a25d3dc3#comment-1181
    https://dmtproperties.net/our-ch-c2/comment-page-1/?unapproved=10719&moderation-hash=38844d619fe6c74a4785ad4b3335ac92#comment-10719
    http://www.loguideas.com.ar/producto/chal-de-mujer/?unapproved=9622&moderation-hash=d99ec78ef4b08dd3e034fabbca03049e#comment-9622
    https://www.baselismail.com/best-bitcoin-exchange-for-day-trading/?unapproved=2336&moderation-hash=3d535bc8b2b29664a44fb23e4bb6d17f#comment-2336
    http://vsktelangana.org/abkm-2016-pressmeet3-telugu/?unapproved=11253&moderation-hash=40432d65bc8ce82ea1490e9db445ff4f#comment-11253
    http://vastutree.com/vastu-remedies-for-kitchen/?unapproved=1391&moderation-hash=073845a12a18dd1745daa7c384441541#comment-1391
    https://blog.linio.com.pe/vive-el-futbol-mundial-2018/?unapproved=7446&moderation-hash=a3f49fd5bfb4192e6fa677fe6125e663#comment-7446
    http://centroslegales.net/blog/2015/05/04/accidentes-de-trabajo/?unapproved=12405&moderation-hash=4a6c25ad7e509195769941ee478ed6d7#comment-12405
    http://www.thaitasty.co/?unapproved=1904&moderation-hash=be15ac88a5c848138b3ba5fe7ba52e70#comment-1904
    http://puticocorobo.cocolog-nifty.com/blog/2007/11/post_3f4e.html
    http://skodarapidclub.ru/forum/showthread.php?p=36667#post36667
    http://www.treatmentsofcancer.com/breast-cancer-risk-factors.html?unapproved=1172&moderation-hash=1400662f4cdd468fdb8bc39f8c47db99#comment-1172
    https://blog.bilderberg.nl/trouwen/ja-ik-wil-niks-vergeten/?unapproved=44629&moderation-hash=48d20e870f487dec451b79f2c698ebd0#comment-44629
    https://ketoan.top/gioi-thieu-ve-ke-toan-ha-noi.html?unapproved=649&moderation-hash=6851d152a6f243e01649604034f85130#comment-649
    https://son-onlus.org/un-concerto-damore-per-la-nostra-speranza/?unapproved=231&moderation-hash=25b1ac5fdb7db0098a76e8abb5f7abd6#comment-231
    http://geosurvey.se/?unapproved=18145&moderation-hash=1b9a2751395821ae77bc333941cc1e86#comment-18145
    http://lacefieldfarms.org/blog/99/?unapproved=1071&moderation-hash=e364966da165ae3269d841c3ce86ad5f#comment-1071
    http://tastyeatsbytess.com/spring-is-in-the-air/?unapproved=10383&moderation-hash=0605ea3c71a98b1d9ad38c6a23a80207#comment-10383
    http://www.siwanut.com/2015/03/13/designing-with-your-clients/?unapproved=2083&moderation-hash=29dd0a4f712a81c3710523d6e0d60814#comment-2083
    https://joseph-hall.com/leanneandchevvypreview/?unapproved=105182&moderation-hash=2e0fdac356f79674f3e2906e6b765f4f#comment-105182
    http://www.steampunkfashion.com/2014/12/welcome-to-steampunkfashion-com/?unapproved=212615&moderation-hash=5c7d1399a7ad3a64814e1e2058264bd6#comment-212615
    http://averydevon.com/hello-world/?unapproved=12601&moderation-hash=a8082cc28371dec883b51f063917f9d6#comment-12601
    http://www.michiganelitefootballclub.com/hello-world/?unapproved=594&moderation-hash=396bf58993c45e550403f1071abed503#comment-594
    http://latin.silkroad.net/2017/08/21/french-latino-historia-de-un-amor/?unapproved=2857&moderation-hash=05a2c8586250008b8f4cb3d4ddfebd6f#comment-2857
    http://cdrisk.com/sample-page?unapproved=33227&moderation-hash=fd4feeb05e2701be38b012de4a131c78#comment-33227
    https://nebulonranger.org/2017/06/03/hello-world/?unapproved=8271&moderation-hash=8d55d750232ee0696158095663b79a3d#comment-8271
    http://www.chairmanfinancebankzambia.com/?unapproved=2138&moderation-hash=efd6ab643e36e98b6f809e12b1a840ce#comment-2138
    https://bescofield.com/hello-world/?unapproved=951&moderation-hash=da568f95dd031f24742ab0d836f773a7#comment-951
    http://brothersstyling.ru/vstrechaem-nash-novyj-logotip/?unapproved=58254&moderation-hash=9d1307bce963e6c24737f8623fc2e64a#comment-58254
    http://sandiegoblog.jll.com/industry-insighter-technology/?unapproved=7142&moderation-hash=307c791a70b1c71bbff94a3c350f340d#comment-7142
    https://cartaosus.com.br/cartao-sus-online.html?unapproved=13457&moderation-hash=2298eb183572c6a504899927a77be1f0#comment-13457
    http://oceancolortechnologies.com/?unapproved=472735&moderation-hash=545a2f61a10cfb6a8db129869a40c6e3#comment-472735
    http://smennecke.de/?p=1&unapproved=21682&moderation-hash=8a2e655a806a775337eeafdb45f2a0cb#comment-21682
    http://thegodfatherofairguns.com/basics/a-short-history-of-the-bb/?unapproved=21669&moderation-hash=8146bdaa745cb858d5a1a762debe3e53#comment-21669
    http://diegolopes.me/cement-mixing-container/?unapproved=612&moderation-hash=875b58014597383a160b09eb2ee29b18#comment-612
    http://startherapyohio.com/2017/07/7160-chagrin-rd/?unapproved=202675&moderation-hash=b251b7e9e49d946f9c934c20e779a08e#comment-202675
    http://www.afrikonnect.com/?unapproved=24474&moderation-hash=c213f3b6ea483bfe77746985be3dd7a3#comment-24474
    http://www.kod-podlaskie.pl/co-z-ta-szkola-debata-o-edukacji-w-lomzy/?unapproved=7197&moderation-hash=34b7c02fb1c307affd4c693c3071cfa3#comment-7197
    http://thuocbenhtri.com/?unapproved=5003&moderation-hash=1925a539be8fcc1b0ef36034a76ba127#comment-5003
    http://earlystarcreative.com/pix-the-panda-is-here/?unapproved=1229&moderation-hash=e11d8f813429e972064dd5daf37fccc6#comment-1229
    https://cyberelektronik.com/ardublock-arduino-ile-gorsel-egitim-56/?unapproved=3201&moderation-hash=078c64430e55eff4f604da38243a4d12#comment-3201
    https://dessencesetdessens.com/2018/03/05/chou-fleur-sain-creatif/?unapproved=2585&moderation-hash=1a3ee5a8250b8fc5d0b6b98b97772846#comment-2585
    https://geppettocatering.com/blog/spring-has-sprung/?unapproved=8452&moderation-hash=4a50ee6c89ae2a69a1af0a787211ae05#comment-8452
    http://nswoc.ca/2017/08/24/caet-launches-members-only-discussion-forum/?unapproved=25295&moderation-hash=e9ad61c23bfd64e682e9ca1f4f75a8c9#comment-25295
    http://vintologyblog.com/a-bitter-love-affair-amaro/?unapproved=8323&moderation-hash=e7eef4ba4f59e19ccc6915a9659404e3#comment-8323
    http://www.boyabatgundemi.com/2016/03/12/dr-suluk-mucizesi/?unapproved=47527&moderation-hash=9b96068b2829f103968fb18bb87bfced#comment-47527
    http://1800hart.com/product/quicken-premier-2016/?unapproved=3630&moderation-hash=85198b64d3132107936aad14d73a8bb8#comment-3630
    http://www.canakkale.net.tr/canakkale-sehitlik-turu.html?unapproved=291658&moderation-hash=fae607d4f1022016c7ab738baf3d77b2#comment-291658
    http://asievenette.fr/all-menus/salade-bo-bun/?unapproved=19293&moderation-hash=c868361f65b521e0a2cb6df9efa0e611#comment-19293
    https://www.oknoplast.it/blog/come-eliminare-i-graffi-dal-vetro/?unapproved=22858&moderation-hash=2d407fd664ee0b9b7fc56fded65c25a2#comment-22858
    http://pimharding.com/markup-html-tags-and-formatting/?unapproved=6236&moderation-hash=6df9d03a78053d8a8ddb64a777da2683#comment-6236
    https://wildroutes.org.uk/blog/the-first-microadventure/?unapproved=13226&moderation-hash=b37bf45fb08fc290e185330101b93018#comment-13226
    http://www.sanchezdelara.com/es/una-ley-cuatro-juristas-y-tres-posturas/?unapproved=3759&moderation-hash=7ef0b13b052fbac88d46a7ceb4144398#comment-3759
    http://kachimori7.com/zissenkizi/musou-orochi-zissen/?unapproved=26838&moderation-hash=6a589403f049c8a6efc88edc3ab70459#comment-26838
    https://generalpostexchange.com/2019/01/05/hello-world/?unapproved=1333&moderation-hash=ba2e53f6e17f49c1af3ace9d3d620e28#comment-1333
    http://ligacaldensedefutbol.com.co/post-576/?unapproved=9640&moderation-hash=5f8898dea50a87cf645edfb3c059dc0d#comment-9640
    http://fenster-dekorplast.de/zweifach-oder-dreifachverglasung-was-ist-besser?unapproved=3775&moderation-hash=f128a2ce65634a3b2451fa12c8e3209d#comment-3775
    http://le-mal-de-taire.com/2017/08/29/carnets-sonores-damazonie/?unapproved=10867&moderation-hash=7be30a11719e925b8d6a8638873bbb43#comment-10867
    http://www.brindabellaprint.com.au/offset-printing-gto-in-action/?unapproved=1489&moderation-hash=c10abebb4225871d8d72f6743766376b#comment-1489
    https://emkubed.com.au/index.php/2015/10/02/our-services/?unapproved=9884&moderation-hash=889b5036e7b1b237dea69aa71ac4bc11#comment-9884
    http://acarbonworld.com/2015/10/when-marginal-utility-approaches-zero/?unapproved=10317&moderation-hash=ba09e02f01b9ef3326ae9e9462f2d1e5#comment-10317
    http://genflexlabel.com/genflex-prints-shrink-sleeves-second-self-beer/?unapproved=17773&moderation-hash=93b5227f6a587b97ef8dceca047ea5df#comment-17773
    http://thepersianpals.com/adopting-two/?unapproved=44405&moderation-hash=e43d1fa76a9b36298ab90c526342657f#comment-44405
    http://www.thesoulofsandiego.com/led-zeppelin-copyright-lawsuit/?unapproved=4387&moderation-hash=b83815a3af177408ed0a41abc5af9873#comment-4387
    http://android.applicationpoker.fr/?unapproved=28402&moderation-hash=e0bebd40e3657fc87cf01f5166c042c5#comment-28402
    https://blog.olacabs.com/welcome-to-ola-money-postpaid/?unapproved=371011&moderation-hash=78941970a36aac6232c8a19d09e2aaba#comment-371011
    http://rocktherainbow.co.uk/hello-world?unapproved=19979&moderation-hash=b30d78c59492e1072070eca50dc4027f#comment-19979
    http://love-ham.com/blog/2008/05/post-273.html?unapproved=26508&moderation-hash=2034f09cb274920fa65768fdd89bfad9#comment-26508
    https://www.depurando.it/estratti/centrifugato-destate/?unapproved=24340&moderation-hash=0d916abc1992d030f71953728711194f#comment-24340

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *